Shelf Styling Farmhouse Style: Thrifted Meets New

If you’ve ever wondered how to style a farmhouse style shelf that feels cozy, collected, and full of character, this one’s for you. I pulled together a mix of old and new pieces to create a look that’s simple yet layered. From thrifted books and aged brass to timeless farmhouse staples like crocks, terra cotta pots, and ironstone dishes. In this post, I’m sharing easy ideas and decor pieces you can use to recreate the same look at home, whether you’re starting fresh or just giving your shelves a seasonal refresh.

Most of the pieces I’ve incorporated into this look are thrift and yard sale finds. Even the shelf itself was a Facebook find, though it looked quite different when I first brought it home. With a little paint and a set of furniture legs, I gave this old cabinet a fresh new life.

It actually sat in my closet for quite some time because I had no idea what to do with it. I even tried giving it away a few times! But as it often happens, inspiration struck when I least expected it — and I’m so glad I held onto it. Now it’s one of my favorite pieces to decorate, layered with a mix of vintage charm and farmhouse character.

I’m sharing a few ideas that I hope inspire you to look at your own pieces in a new way. Decorating doesn’t have to mean buying all new things — sometimes it’s about thinking outside the box and finding creative ways to style what you already have. Many of the most charming vintage vignettes come from reimagining old treasures and giving them new life in a fresh setting.

1. Vintage Champagne Bucket as a Vase

One of my favorite ways to style a shelf is by using unexpected pieces as vases. This vintage champagne bucket adds just the right amount of patina and character while keeping the look elegant. I filled it with a few simple dried stems to create height and texture without overpowering the rest of the vignette. It’s a reminder that beautiful decor doesn’t have to come straight from a big-box store. Sometimes reinventing an old piece gives it new life, and those are often the ones that end up becoming your favorites.

2. Books are a Great Filler!

Books are one of my favorite ways to fill in empty shelf space while adding instant character. Stacked upright or laid flat, they bring warmth, height, and that perfectly lived-in feel every farmhouse look needs. I stuck these inside an old metal serving tray piece. I love mixing hardcovers in muted tones or faded spines. Awhile back, I was able to get several Nancy Drew books on an online auction, so I used those and stuck an old doorknob in the mix also!

3. Mixing Old & New

Plates are the one thing I swore I’d never look for when I was out antiquing or thrifting, but time has a funny way of changing our minds. I’m rarely lucky enough to find a full matching set, but there’s no shortage of beautiful single ladies that always seem to call my name. This red transferware ironstone plate was a recent find. Just one piece, but when mixed with the right colors and textures, it fits in perfectly with my other misfit treasures. The wire basket is new, but adding a soft linen underneath helps tie everything together and makes the whole display feel intentional and collected.

4. Vintage Postcards Help Tell a Story

I love adding old postcards and handwritten notes to my displays — they instantly bring a sense of history and nostalgia. This one, written to someone in River Rouge, Michigan, dates back to the early 1900s. I like to imagine the stories behind these pieces and the people who wrote them, their everyday lives captured in a few thoughtful lines. And while I couldn’t quite decipher every word of this cursive script, that mystery is part of the charm.

5. Crocks

Crocks really don’t need much of an explanation, if you see one for a good price, grab it! This one has a crack, but I tend to reach for those pieces with a little character over something perfectly blemish-free. I tucked in a couple of wooden rolling pins and added a simple doily to break up the brown tones, creating a soft and cozy contrast that fits right in with the farmhouse feel.

If you’re looking for more farmhouse shelf decor ideas, here are a few extra views of how I mixed vintage finds with newer pieces to create this look.

Save

Save

Save

If you love creating cozy farmhouse displays, don’t be afraid to mix textures, colors, and eras. Vintage finds, yard-sale treasures, and simple everyday items can come together in the most unexpected ways. That’s what makes decorating so rewarding. The beauty is in the story each piece tells. If you enjoyed this shelf styling, you might also love my DIY Farmhouse Cloche Project. Until next time, thank you for stopping by Auburn at Home. 🤍

You can find more of my favorite vintage-inspired pieces and styling ideas on my Amazon Storefront or my Pinterest boards.

This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting Auburn At Home — it helps me keep creating and sharing more farmhouse inspiration with you!